Tuesday, February 9, 2010
Welcome Visitor! | login/logout
 

Keep it local, attorneys say
Email Print
NORTHFIELD — Local attorneys and others are sticking up for the two Northfield lawyers who will likely lose their city contracts to metro-area attorneys next year, saying that work should be awarded to local firms instead.

When the City Council solicited proposals for legal representation this summer, three local lawyers — including current City Attorney Maren Swanson and City Prosecutor Tim Morisette, both of Northfield’s Lampe Law Group — submitted proposals. An interview panel composed of city directors and the mayor rejected the city’s current counsel and a third Northfielder, John Fossum, who had no prosecuting experience.

No other local attorneys applied.

City officials have said the likely contract winners, Chris Hood of Flaherty and Hood in St. Paul and Elliot Knetsch of Campbell Knutson in Eagan, were chosen based on their undisclosed prices, experience and the availability of other lawyers at their firms.

But Swanson and Morisette, in a joint statement, said the decision marked a disappointing shift of city taxdollars away from local businesses, and the subject of outsourcing professional services — not just legal representation — has generated interest among the city’s business community, said Chamber President Jeff Hasse.

“We have taken a lot of calls on that,” he said.

At a Chamber forum Wednesday, Mayor Mary Rossing defended the recommendation to contract with the new attorneys, saying the decision by her and the city staff on the interview panel accounted for more than just location.

“I would have loved to interview a dozen local attorneys,” she said. “If that was a wake-up call to all our local professionals, this is the way we’re doing business now. … You need to step up (and apply) if you want that job.”




Rossing emphasized that the panel’s rejection of the Lampe lawyers, who have served in their current capacities since 1988, was “in no way a reflection of past services.”

But sending the city’s legal dollars out of town “sends a bad signal” at a time when the Chamber of Commerce and Northfield Downtown Development Corporation are encouraging residents to do their own spending locally, Northfield barrister David Ludescher said.

“(City Attorney Swanson) was perhaps the only thing that was stable about the council decisions, giving you good advice ... I don’t think it was Maren that was the problem, it was the council not being able to manage themselves,” he said.

Ludescher, whose firm has represented Dundas, said the local legal community didn’t think the city would drop the Lampe lawyers or that their own firms would meet the city’s qualifications.

“We’ve put in applications before and haven’t even had an interview,” he said.

Greg Colby, a 30-year criminal attorney and a state public defender, called Morisette a responsive, experienced and compassionate attorney.

“He really is very, very good at what he does,” Colby said.

Other attorneys, like former Lampe lawyer Carl Arnold, said outsourcing the legal work will cost more in the long run and result in poorer service.

Neither Colby nor Arnold applied for the work.

Even the Faribault-based Hope Center, an advocacy organization for victims of domestic and sexual abuse, got in on the action. Speaking to the council on an unrelated symbolic declaration this week, Executive Director Erica Staab said an out-of-town prosecutor would make criminal cases more difficult for victims, who often travel to Northfield to meet with Morisette if he can’t meet them in Faribault.

“When people are in the midst of crisis they require more time,” she said. “Somebody that’s willing to meet the client where they’re at, literally and figuratively, is incredibly important.”

The City Council could approve the three-year contracts that start in 2010 as soon as its regularly scheduled 7 p.m. Nov. 2 meeting at City Hall.

— Jim Hammerand covers the city. He can be reached at jhammerand@northfieldnews.com or 645-1114.
Share: 

Guidelines: Welcome to the Northfield News community. Please keep your comments civil. Don't attack other readers personally and keep your language decent. If you would like to report abuse click here to notify us.
 
Member Opinions:
By: OnlytheFacts on 10/23/09
Everyone should stop shopping at the Mayor's store, and let her try to survive on her salary from the city!

By: dapa2 on 10/24/09
It will be interesting to see what the new contracts came in at once approved should be available as public information.

By: jd318us on 10/25/09
I was a police officer in Northfield for over 20 years and Tim Morisette was the city prosecutor for the bulk of the time I was there. Prior to Mr. Morisette's time, the Lampe firm had the contract as well. Not only is he, as Greg Colby said, very good at his job, he has always been very dedicated to helping out the officers at ANY time of the day or night, including calls at 3:00 am when a complicated situation arose. I can't help but think that a law firm in another city just won't be as easy to deal with in those circumstances. Also, the convenience of being able to stop in his office to review a complaint being drafted or to clarify an important point or to go over testimony before trial can never be matched by doing things remotely over the phone or by email.
I can't see how anyone will be the better for this. Remember the adages "Bigger isn't always better" and "If it works, leave it alone."

By: Peter on 10/25/09
As much asI support trying to keep business local, there is one or two elements which should override my previous statement.

Qualification and money. It is not uncommon that governments tend to overpay for services that are farmed out.
Like in everything else our city officials should be striving to get the best value for our tax dollars.

This means getting the right service at the right price.

By: fairandbalanced on 10/26/09
If we all knew the real reason that this firm wasn't rehired, and if it was a good reason...I think people would understand why we didn't shop local. As it is, there's no good reason, so it doesn't make sense.

By: Townie on 10/29/09
Losing Tim could be a big screw-up for the City of Northfield..... I agree whole-heartedly with many of these comments, expecially that of jd318us. Tim Morisette, in particulary has done an awesome job for the City of Northfield; approachable, responsive, etc. And I happen to enjoy exchanging "hello's!' with my city prosecutor when I run in to him at the Quarterback Club, over the lunch-hour. I'm thinking any new "metro attorney's" won't be exchanging hello's with the locals; and what *is* the particular interest in these metro attorney's, anyway? Is there something for a city official to gain buy choosing these two particular people? What *is* the REAL reason behind changing city prosecutors, anyway? Hopefully our City Officials won't make a foolish decision that we will have to bail ourselves out of later down the road....

By: Observer23 on 10/29/09
Residents are consistently encouraged to "Shop Local,", so why then doesn't that apply to our city council? We have many fine professionals available to us in town, use them! And if our elected officials aren't going to shop locally for professional services, then the citizens shouldn't be asked to show any loyalties to the local businesses either -- won't that be a fine outcome.

By: EditorJaci on 10/29/09
Observer, how would the city do that if no other local firms applied for the contract?

 
Login and voice your opinion!  


Video

I35 Marketplace Home

Featured Business:
Top Jobs | Top Homes | Top Cars 
Top Jobs
Agriculture Monsanto, a leading company in the seed t...
Retail-- Account Service Manager Mature, hard-working,...
General-- Cannon Valley Vet Clinic Northfield Open P...
TRYSTAR is looking for a full time Logistics Coordinator to...
Industrial- Platers- All Flex Currently has several...